A good trades reference check is a phone call to a technician’s former supervisor, with the same open, job-specific questions asked for every finalist and notes taken on what was actually said. It covers the work the technician did alone, callbacks, customer handling, attendance, safety and whether the shop would rehire. This guide gives contractors the process, the questions and a way to read the answers.

Petratalent
Build Confidence in Your Next Hire
Petra Talent recruits and vets HVAC and plumbing professionals, supporting contractors with role-specific sourcing and technical screening.

Visit

TL;DR

  • Call the person who managed the technician, not a friend or coworker, and get the candidate’s consent first.
  • Run the check late in the process, by phone, once you are down to a few finalists.
  • Ask the same open questions of every reference: independent work, callbacks, difficult customers, safety, attendance, rehire.
  • Treat hesitation, flat answers and praise with no specifics as information.
  • Verify required licenses and certifications with the issuing body, not the candidate’s word.

Table of Contents

What a reference check can tell a contractor

The U.S. Office of Personnel Management (OPM) describes reference checking as an objective evaluation of past job performance, based on people such as supervisors and peers. It is used to verify résumé claims, compare experience to job competencies and uncover information other steps missed. The principle behind it is that past performance predicts future performance.

Three purposes of a skilled-trades reference check

For HVAC and plumbing, that matters because the work happens away from you. A technician spends the day in customers’ homes and buildings. An interview shows how someone talks about the work. A former supervisor can say how the work held up, how many jobs came back and how the person treated the customer.

OPM’s guide says candidates typically provide three references. They should be professional (current or previous supervisors, coworkers), not personal ones such as friends or relatives. Employers should also get the candidate’s consent before making contact.

In practice, contractors should:

  1. Ask for at least one direct supervisor, such as a lead, service manager or foreman, from the last two shops.
  2. Get written permission to call.
  3. Ask each reference whether they know someone else who worked with the candidate. Trades are a small world in any metro area, and a second-degree contact is often more candid.

If the candidate does not want a current employer called. OPM’s guidance is to agree to contact that supervisor only after a tentative offer, or to ask for alternative references. If a reference will only confirm dates and title, ask the candidate for another. A candidate who cannot name any supervisor from recent jobs has told you something too.

How to run the call

OPM notes that checks usually come near the end of selection, after the field is narrowed, and most are done by phone. A call lets you probe for detail and takes less of the reference’s time.

A workable call runs in this order:

  1. Introduce yourself and the position in a sentence.
  2. Confirm the basics: how the reference knows the candidate, the candidate’s title and the dates of employment. Check these against the résumé.
  3. Move to open-ended questions about behavior the reference actually saw.
  4. Ask the rehire question last, then stay quiet. The most useful remark often comes after the first polite answer.

Use the same core questions for every reference and write down the answers in the reference’s words. Answers can only be compared when the questions matched. Keep questions job-related, avoid protected characteristics such as age, race, religion or disability, and keep the notes on file with the signed authorization.

Reference check questions for HVAC and plumbing technicians

A university hiring toolkit offers a standard reference form built on responsibilities, correct and timely work, attendance, tardiness and rehire. Those basics carry over to the trades. The questions below adapt them to service and construction work.

Scope and independence

  • What kind of work did this person handle on their own, and what did they need help with?
  • What systems or fixtures did they work on most: residential service, light commercial, new construction, rough-in, controls?
  • Did they run their own calls, or ride with a lead?

Quality and callbacks

  • How often did their work come back? Can you give an example of a repair that did not hold and what they did about it?
  • Did they close out jobs fully, with notes, photos and paperwork?
  • How did they care for the truck, tools and parts inventory?

Callbacks are the cost behind a weak hire. Our guide on why HVAC callbacks increase with bad hires shows why this line of questions earns its time.

Customers and teamwork

  • Tell me about a time they dealt with an angry customer or a job that went sideways. What happened?
  • How did they work with dispatch, the crew and other trades?
  • Did customers ever ask for them by name, or ask you to send someone else?

Safety

  • How would you rate their safety habits from 1 to 10?
  • Were there any incidents or near-misses, and how did they respond to safety feedback?
  • Would you trust them to work safely without direct supervision?

Reliability and fit

  • How was their attendance and punctuality?
  • Why did they leave?
  • If you were hiring today, would you rehire them, and in what role?

For a hands-on picture to pair with these answers, see our guides on interviewing HVAC service techs and commercial plumber interview questions.

How to read the answers

The American Employers Alliance recommends specific behavioral questions over vague ones. It also notes that a reference who is specific in some areas and vague in others is giving you useful information.

A simple scoring habit helps:

What you hear What it usually means
A situation, what the tech did and how it ended A reference who saw the work. Weigh it heavily.
Glowing words with no example Unverified. Ask for a specific job.
Short, flat answers or only dates and title Incomplete. Ask for another reference.
A pause before the rehire question Treat it as an answer and probe gently.
Candidate owns a past mistake and says what changed A good sign for field accountability.

Compare each answer against what the candidate told you in the interview. Mismatches in roles, dates or scope are the first thing to resolve.

What a reference check cannot cover

A phone call does not show whether someone can diagnose a system. Pair it with a short practical test. Our plumbing skills assessment guide covers what to test and how to score it. If you want to see a candidate on a job, read the rules in one-shift working interviews, because unpaid trial work can create wage-and-hour exposure under the Fair Labor Standards Act.

Licenses and certifications are also not a reference matter. Confirm any required state license or EPA Section 608 certification with the issuing body. Our guide to how plumbing workforce vetting works explains where those checks fit.

Doing this at volume

For a contractor with one open seat, a careful reference check is a few hours of a manager’s time. When several technician, project manager or superintendent roles are open, the calls, notes and verification stack up on top of running jobs.

Petra Talent recruits only for HVAC and plumbing, and its Technical Vetting & Workforce Solutions service covers technical vetting, credential verification and market wage consulting. Placements carry a one-time placement fee of 18%, and the pricing page lists the payment options.

Petratalent

Contractors hiring for service or construction roles can start with HVAC Recruiting Services or Plumbing Recruiting Services.

Our view on trades references

Most hiring mistakes in the trades show up months after the offer letter, as callbacks, no-shows and a crew that loses patience. The reference call is the cheapest place to see them coming, and it only works when the questions are specific to the trade.

We recruit only for HVAC and plumbing contractors, so we see hiring as workforce alignment and retention, not just filling a seat. That is why our process pairs technical vetting and credential verification with market wage consulting: a technician who is verified, paid at market and matched to the role is more likely to stay.

A reference check is one piece of that. Contractors who run it consistently, with the same questions, written notes and a real rehire question, make better offers.

David

FAQ

How many references should a contractor check for a technician?

Three is typical, and OPM’s guide says candidates usually supply three. Make sure at least one is a direct supervisor. If answers conflict, ask for another before deciding.

Do you need the candidate’s permission to call a reference?

Yes, as a matter of practice. OPM’s guide advises employers to get the candidate’s consent, and keeping the signed authorization on file documents that you did. Ask for it in writing before the first call.

What if a former employer will only confirm dates and title?

That is common. Thank them, record what they confirmed and ask the candidate for another supervisor or lead. Do not push a reluctant contact for opinions.

When in the hiring process should references be checked?

Near the end, once you have a short list of finalists, and before or alongside a conditional offer. This keeps the time spent on calls to the candidates you would actually hire.

Sources

Post a comment

Your email address will not be published.

Related Posts