There is no federal pay transparency law for private employers, but as of CauseComp’s list reviewed October 23, 2026, 14 states plus D.C. require pay information in job postings. For HVAC, plumbing and mechanical contractors, the practical rule is simple: if a technician, estimator or project manager role touches one of those states, the posting needs a good-faith pay range. The details on size thresholds, remote roles and penalties differ by state, and they decide whether your posting is compliant.
TL;DR
- The 14 states plus D.C. with posting rules are Colorado, California, Washington, Hawaii, Illinois, Minnesota, New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Maryland, Vermont, Massachusetts, Maine and Virginia. Delaware follows on September 26, 2027.
- Thresholds run from any employer size (Colorado, Maryland, Connecticut, Virginia, D.C.) to 50 or more employees (Hawaii).
- Remote and out-of-state roles can still be covered if the worker reports to a supervisor or office in the state.
- Union contractors in some states can use the collective bargaining agreement (CBA) wage schedule as the range.
- Build pay bands before you post. A range you cannot defend is the main compliance risk.
Table of Contents
- What pay transparency laws actually require
- Which states require salary ranges in job postings
- What this means for HVAC and plumbing contractors
- What a compliant posting includes
- Penalties and recordkeeping
- Salary history and pay discussions
- A practical compliance routine
- Our perspective
- Hiring with a recruiter who knows trade pay
- FAQ
- Sources
What pay transparency laws actually require
Pay transparency laws require employers to share wage information with applicants and employees in set situations. According to the Cornell Journal of Law and Public Policy, the most expansive laws require wage information in job postings. Others require it at a point in hiring, such as after the first interview or at the offer. The most lenient require it only when someone asks.

Contractors mostly face the first type. A posting for a service technician in Denver or a plumbing foreman in Seattle must state the pay, not just “competitive.” Some states also add a description of benefits and other compensation, which matters in trades where overtime, on-call pay, bonuses and vehicle programs are part of the offer.
Which states require salary ranges in job postings
The threshold is what makes the list uneven. CauseComp’s summary of the thresholds:
| Employer size | Where it applies |
|---|---|
| Any size | Colorado, Maryland, D.C., Connecticut, Virginia |
| 4 or more employees | New York State, New York City, Ithaca |
| 5 or more | Vermont |
| 10 or more | Maine; New Jersey (over 20 calendar weeks) |
| 15 or more | California, Washington, Illinois, Cleveland, Columbus |
| 25 or more | Massachusetts |
| 30 or more | Minnesota |
| 50 or more | Hawaii |
| More than 25 | Delaware (from September 26, 2027) |
Local rules sit on top of state rules. New York City, Ithaca, Westchester County, Cleveland and Columbus have their own, and where a city and a state both have a law, the posting must satisfy both, per the same list. Check the current list before each hiring push, because states keep adding laws.
Recent changes
Jackson Lewis reports three 2026 changes. Virginia’s law took effect July 1, 2026, and applies to all employers. Maine’s LD 54 took effect July 29, 2026, for employers with 10 or more employees. Connecticut’s amended law took effect October 1, 2026, moving disclosure into the job advertisement itself. Ogletree points out that these laws differ in significant ways, so one posting template will not satisfy every state.
What this means for HVAC and plumbing contractors
Remote, multi-state and field roles
Many contractors assume a job site in another state is the only trigger. It is not. New York’s Department of Labor says jobs performed at least in part in New York need a range, including remote jobs that report to a New York supervisor, office or worksite. Maryland covers postings where work is physically performed at least in part in Maryland, but not roles with only occasional Maryland work. Jackson Lewis notes Connecticut’s law likewise reaches out-of-state positions reporting to a Connecticut office.
A dispatcher, estimator or project manager based elsewhere but reporting into one of these states can trigger the rule.

Union and prevailing wage work
For union mechanical contractors in Massachusetts, the Boston NECA chapter advises that the wage schedule in the applicable CBA can serve as the pay range. It also says temporary and seasonal employees count toward the 25-employee threshold, and that the rule reaches postings placed by staffing agencies. For multi-state projects, coverage generally follows the employee’s primary place of work, typically where most hours are performed.
Delaware is narrower: CBA-approved compensation must be disclosed only for opportunities covered by agreements executed, amended or renewed after September 26, 2027, per Seyfarth’s compendium.
Commission and flat-rate pay
Trade pay is rarely a single hourly number. Seyfarth’s compendium says that for Colorado, commission-paid jobs require disclosure of the commission basis rather than a range, and tipped jobs require the base wage or range. Contractors who pay flat rate, hybrid or commission to plumbers and service technicians should decide how each plan is described before posting. Our guide to plumbing pay plans covers the common structures, and the same logic applies to how subcontractor crews get paid on the project side.
What a compliant posting includes
Content rules differ, so use the strictest state you hire in as your baseline.
- A real minimum and maximum. New York does not accept open-ended ranges such as “$17 an hour and up,” and the range must be a good-faith annual salary, piece rate or hourly rate.
- Benefits and other pay where required. Maryland requires a general description of benefits and other compensation. Colorado also requires the application close date and how to apply, per Seyfarth. New York, by contrast, says the range itself should not include benefits or paid time off.
- The range inside the posting. California requires employers with 15 or more employees to include the pay scale in ads, including third-party postings, and links or QR codes do not replace it, per Experian.
- Third-party postings. Job boards and staffing agency ads count in several states, including New Jersey and California.
Delaware and some other states exempt temporary or interim jobs requiring immediate hire, but disclosure before an offer or on request likely still applies.
Penalties and recordkeeping
Penalties vary widely. Colorado violations can reach $500 to $10,000 each. Maine’s civil penalty is $100 to $500 per violation, with position and pay history kept for three years after separation. New Jersey sets up to $300 for a first violation and $600 for each later one, according to Trusaic’s guide. Delaware gives a written warning for a first violation, then $500 to $10,000, per the National Law Review.
Washington gives a five-business-day notice-and-cure period from July 27, 2025 through July 27, 2027, per Experian. Maryland requires a compliance record for each position for at least three years, per its labor department FAQ.
California employers with 100 or more employees also file annual pay data reports. From January 1, 2027, the reportable job categories rise from 10 to 23, according to Jones Day.
Salary history and pay discussions
Several of these states pair posting rules with limits on asking about pay history. Washington bars employers from seeking an applicant’s wage history, with narrow exceptions, and from stopping employees from discussing wages. Virginia’s 2026 law includes a salary history ban and protects people who request a range, per Ogletree. Interview scripts for service managers should drop the “what are you making now” question wherever you hire. This is a legal area, so have employment counsel confirm your interview and posting practices.
A practical compliance routine
- Map where each role is performed and who it reports to. Include remote and hybrid roles.
- Set pay bands first. Tie each range to role, license level and market data. Our article on pay bands for skilled trades shows how contractors build them.
- Check current market pay. Ranges that sit far below the market draw no applicants. Our HVAC technician pay data is a starting point.
- Use one template per strictest state. Add the benefits, close date and application details where required.
- Keep records. Retain each posting and how the range was set for at least the longest period in the states you hire in.
- Review internal pay. A public range invites comparison from current employees. Fix compression before you post.
Our perspective
Contractors tell us the posting rule is the easy part. The hard part is that a published range is a promise to the market and to your own crew.
We focus only on HVAC and plumbing hiring, and market wage consulting is part of how we work. Candidates read a range and ask whether it matches the license, the on-call load and the truck. A range built on real market data gets stronger applicants and fewer surprises at offer.
That is why we treat pay bands and recruiting as one job. Our direct hire placements start with where the role actually pays in the market, so the posting is something you can stand behind.
David
Hiring with a recruiter who knows trade pay
Pay ranges now go on every posting, so wage data and technical screening matter earlier in the process. Petra Talent places HVAC and plumbing technicians, project managers and leaders, and offers market wage consulting and credential verification alongside sourcing. The one-time placement fee is 18%, and flexible payment options are available. See our HVAC recruiting services or plumbing recruiting services.

FAQ
Is there a federal pay transparency law for contractors?
No. Requirements come from states and some cities. A contractor with employees or openings in several states has to follow each state’s rule, and where a city and state both have one, the posting must meet both.
Do small HVAC and plumbing companies have to post pay ranges?
It depends on the state. Colorado, Maryland, Connecticut, Virginia and D.C. apply regardless of size. Others start at 4, 5, 10, 15, 25, 30 or 50 employees, so count your headcount in each state using that state’s method.
Does a remote or out-of-state role count?
Often yes. New York, Maryland and Connecticut reach roles that are partly performed in the state or that report to a supervisor or office there. Check the state’s official guidance for each role.
Can I use my union wage scale as the pay range?
In Massachusetts, the Boston NECA chapter advises that the CBA wage schedule can be used. Delaware has its own CBA rule starting September 26, 2027. Confirm the approach for your state with counsel.
Sources
- Pay Transparency Laws: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly? (Cornell Journal of Law and Public Policy)
- Pay Transparency Laws: State and City List (CauseComp)
- Pay Transparency Act FAQ (New York State Department of Labor)
- Wage Range Transparency FAQ (Maryland Department of Labor)
- Massachusetts Pay Transparency Law (Boston NECA)
- Pay Transparency Wage Range Disclosure Compendium (Seyfarth)
- Midyear Pay Transparency Update (Jackson Lewis)
- Virginia and Maine Enact Pay Transparency Laws (Ogletree)
- Pay Transparency and 2026 Enforcement Priorities (Experian)
- Maine Labor Standards Webinar (Maine Bureau of Labor Standards)
- New Jersey Pay Transparency Guide (Trusaic)
- Delaware Enacts Pay Transparency Law (National Law Review)
- A Review of 2025 Labor & Employment Legislation in California (Jones Day)