A salary history ban stops an employer from asking an applicant what they earned before, and in most places from using that number to decide whether to hire or what to offer. For HVAC and plumbing contractors, the practical answer is the same in every state: build each offer around the budgeted pay range for the role, ask about expectations instead of past pay, and apply that one routine at every branch, because the rules differ by state and city.

Petratalent
Build More Consistent Hiring Practices
Petra Talent supports mechanical contractors with industry-specific recruiting, technical vetting, and workforce compliance support.

Visit

TL;DR

  • A salary history ban bars employers from asking about prior pay and, in most laws, from relying on it in hiring or setting pay.
  • Roughly twenty states plus D.C. have statewide rules, and many cities add their own. Each state’s labor department publishes the current text.
  • Asking what pay a candidate expects is generally allowed. Asking what the candidate made, or probing for it, is not.
  • Some laws, including Oregon’s, now reach employment agencies, so recruiters working for you are covered too.
  • The safest policy for contractors hiring in several states is one rule everywhere: pay is set by the role’s range, not by the last paycheck.

Table of Contents

What a salary history ban means in practice

The laws share one idea. A new hire’s pay should reflect the job and the person’s skills, not what a previous employer happened to pay. Illinois’ Department of Labor states that an employer may not request or require wage or salary history as a condition of being considered for employment, whether the job is temporary or permanent, hourly or salaried.

For a mechanical contractor, that touches several everyday moments:

  • the application form and any “current pay” field
  • the phone screen and the first interview
  • reference and background checks
  • the offer conversation
  • an agency or recruiter acting on your behalf

A technician who was underpaid at a previous shop is the typical beneficiary. A lead tech with a strong track record who earned little at a small outfit should be priced against your range, not against that history.

Which states have salary history bans

As of an August 2026 guide, eighteen states plus D.C. had statewide pay history restrictions, including California, Colorado, Connecticut, Illinois, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York, Oregon, Virginia and Washington. Counts vary by publisher because cities and counties add local ordinances, and new laws take effect on a schedule. Treat any list as a starting point and confirm against the state labor department page before you change a hiring form.

Three points matter for contractors:

  1. Local laws can be stricter than state law. Ohio, for example, has no statewide ban, yet Cincinnati’s code makes it unlawful to inquire about salary history or screen applicants on prior wages.
  2. Laws keep arriving. Virginia’s pay transparency law took effect on July 1, 2026, and Maine’s job-posting pay range requirement for employers with 10 or more employees took effect on July 29, 2026, as reported by employment lawyers at Ogletree.
  3. Service territory counts. A contractor based in a state without a ban may still hire in a metro area that has one.

What you can ask, and what you cannot

The line is consistent across the statutes we reviewed: expectations are fine, history is not.

Situation Typically allowed Typically prohibited
Application and screening Asking about desired pay range Asking for current or past pay, even in an optional field
Interview Stating the role’s range and asking if it fits Follow-up questions meant to draw out past pay
Candidate volunteers prior pay Depends on the state Relying on it in states such as Illinois
After a written offer Confirming history in some states Using it to lower the offer

The details differ, so it helps to see how the states handle the same facts.

New York and Illinois

New York’s Labor Law Section 194-a, effective January 6, 2020, prohibits employers from asking for salary history orally or in writing, directly or through an agent, and from relying on it to decide whether to interview, offer, or what to pay. Illinois goes further: even if an applicant offers prior pay voluntarily, the employer may not consider or rely on it in deciding on employment or compensation.

Hawaii and Washington

Hawaii’s statute bars employers and employment agencies from inquiring about salary history, but it allows salary expectation discussions and lets an employer consider and verify history the applicant volunteers without prompting. Washington’s RCW 49.58.100 forbids seeking wage history from the applicant or a former employer, and allows confirmation only if the applicant voluntarily discloses it or after an offer with compensation has been made.

Maine

The Maine Attorney General’s guidance says employers may ask about compensation expectations but should avoid follow-ups such as asking what an expectation is based on, because the answer could elicit salary history. Field supervisors and office managers who run interviews informally are where this slips.

Supervisor asking an applicant about pay expectations

Recruiters and agencies are covered too

A contractor cannot hand the question to someone else. New York’s rule applies to employers acting personally or through an agent. Hawaii’s statute names employment agencies. Oregon’s HB 2746, operative January 1, 2026, extends salary history protections to employment agencies, adds wage range and benefits disclosure requirements, and sets penalties that begin with a letter of education and then move to $1,000 civil penalties.

That is why contractors should ask any recruiter how candidates are screened and what is passed along in a submission. A candidate summary should cover licenses, certifications, tools, service or install experience and availability, not previous pay.

A compliant process for HVAC and plumbing hiring

  1. Set the range before you post. Decide the hourly or salary range for each role, with the pay plan attached: hourly, flat rate, commission or hybrid. Our guide to plumbing pay plans shows how each structure changes total compensation.
  2. Remove pay history from forms. Delete current-pay and prior-pay fields from applications, scorecards and ATS templates, even optional ones. Washington’s labor agency policy says an optional question is still not allowed.
  3. Script the pay conversation. Interviewers state the range and ask whether it works. If a candidate mentions prior pay, do not follow up and, in strict states, do not use it.
  4. Benchmark against the market, not the person. Use local wage data for the trade and the role. Our pages on HVAC technician pay, plumber salary and plumbing foreman salary give current benchmarks.
  5. Keep notes on how the offer was set. Record the role range, the candidate’s licenses and experience, and the reasoning. That is the record you want if an offer is questioned.
  6. Standardize onboarding. After the offer, paperwork such as I-9 verification for employers should follow one routine across locations, so a branch in one state does not run a different process from another.

Why one rule beats a state-by-state patchwork

Contractors with service territories in several states face a practical problem. A dispatcher in a ban state, a project manager in a state without one and an estimator in a city with its own ordinance may all be interviewing in the same week. A single company-wide policy of never asking about prior pay is easier to train and audit than a map of exceptions. The same advice appears in an August 2026 guide for employers hiring across several states: stop asking about pay history everywhere and build offers around the budgeted range. Our page on multi-state hiring compliance covers the wider picture for HVAC and plumbing contractors.

Perspective

Contractors tell us the hard part of this rule is not the law, it is habit. Experienced owners and service managers have always asked “what are you making now?” because it is quick. Under these laws that shortcut is gone in a growing number of places, and it should be replaced with something better.

We start every search with the role’s market range. Our work includes market wage benchmarking and technical vetting, so the conversation with a candidate is about the license, the trade skills and the fit with the pay plan, not about the last employer’s payroll. A range set up front also protects retention: a technician who is offered a fair figure for the role has less reason to keep looking.

For contractors hiring in more than one state, that approach means one process everywhere, instead of a different script for each branch.

David

Hiring HVAC and plumbing talent with a range-first approach

Petra Talent recruits exclusively for HVAC and plumbing, across service, construction, leadership and technical roles in the United States. Our services include role-specific sourcing, technical vetting, credential verification and market wage consulting, so contractors can price a role from the market before the first interview. The fee is a one-time placement fee of 18%, with details on the pricing page. Contractors can also see how HVAC recruiting and plumbing recruiting searches work.

Petratalent

FAQ

Which states have a salary history ban?

Roughly twenty states plus D.C. restrict salary history questions, including California, Colorado, Connecticut, Illinois, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York, Oregon, Virginia and Washington, along with many cities. Lists change as new laws take effect, so check the state labor department site for the current text.

Can I ask a candidate what pay they expect?

In most ban states, yes. Hawaii and Cincinnati expressly allow salary expectation discussions. New York is stricter, so the safest practice is to state your range and ask whether it works, rather than asking for a number.

What if the candidate tells me their old salary without being asked?

It depends on the state. Hawaii allows an employer to consider history volunteered without prompting, while Illinois does not allow reliance on it. Under a single company policy, interviewers do not use it either way.

Do these laws apply to the recruiter I use?

Often, yes. New York covers requests made through an agent, Hawaii names employment agencies, and Oregon’s 2026 law extends its protections to employment agencies. Contractors should confirm that any recruiter’s screening leaves pay history out.

Sources

Post a comment

Your email address will not be published.

Related Posts